Book Review: Men Explain Things to Me by Rebecca Solnit

At the end of last year or the beginning of this, before my focus and attention were hijacked by the circus that is American politics, The New York Times did a piece on what books people had read the previous year. There were about fifty panelists, mostly writers, but mixed with a sampling of actors, scientists, business people, and politicians. What I could not help but notice is that every third person or so listed two books by Rebecca Solnit. Not the same two books, but two books. No one, it seemed read one Rebecca Solnit book; they had always gone on to a second or a third.

2083

Rebecca Solnit  (photograph by John Lee for The Guardian)

I had done the same a few years earlier. A friend had lent me a copy of Infinite City: A San Francisco Atlas, Solnit’s whimsical collection of “should-be” maps of San Francisco neighborhoods, which had, of course, immediately led me to another title Wanderlust: A History of Walking, which is much more fascinating than it sounds; as the blurb says, it is a history of walking as a political and cultural activity. (Solnit has also done atlases of New York and New Orleans.)

But then I moved on to other books, to other writers, although I did not forget about her. One couldn’t; she was everywhere: her essays appearing in journals, her pieces in major newspapers, her name cited in political commentary, her books brought up in serious conversation.

This year, after reading the NYTimes piece, I realized it had been a while since I last read her, so I bought and read A Field Guide to Getting Lost in January. However, I did not immediately read another. Instead, I fell down a rabbit hole of books about walking and cities and travel: Flanneuse by Lauren Elkin, The Only Street in Paris by Elaine Scillonian, Sidewalks by Valeria Luiselli and Time Travel: A History by James Gleick. This is what a good book can do.

So now in early autumn I return to Solnit once more.

Men Explain Things to Me is a menexplaincollection of seven essays, mostly first-published on the web-site TomDispatch, that focus on the reality and the dangers (and some of the absurdity) found in the patriarchy of modern civilization, dangers that include murder, violence, and rape, as well as condescension and subordination.

The opening essay, “Men Explain Things to Me,” begins with the humorous anecdote where at a party a man says he heard she was a writer and asks her what she has written. She mentions the last book she has written–a study of Eadweard Muybridge and the technology of the west–and he says what a shame that it was published the same year that another book on the same subject came out. He then goes on to explain the substance of this “other book.” As he continues with his description of the book that she should read, Solnit recognizes that he is talking about her book.

Talk about mansplaining!

In an article for The Guardian this past August, Solnit wrote:

There are no signs that mansplaining is going away. An acquaintance recently told me, “A man once asked me if I knew of the Bracero program [for Mexican farmworkers in the US], and when I said, ‘Why yes, I wrote my undergrad thesis about it,’ he replied, ‘Well, I’ll tell you about it.’ I said, ‘No, I’ll tell you, fucker!’ And then the dinner party got weird.”

But the humor of such situations is more than tempered by the grisly facts that anchor these essays. For instance, in the U.S. more women have been killed by domestic violence between 9/11 and the year 2012 than the total number of people who died in the towers AND in the two wars fought afterwards

We have a war on terror…but it seems we’re concentrating on the wrong terror.

And if domestic homocide is rampant, rape is epidemic and systematic. (Just read this month’s headlines.) There is a reported rape in the United States once every 6.2 minutes.

In one essay, Solnit reports the details of the Dominique Strauss-Kahn rape. (He, the French head of the International Monetary Fund; she the African immigrant maid at the luxury hotel he was staying in.) It was more than just rape, Solnit states. It was a political analogy come to life. As she writes:

Her name was Africa. His was France. He colonized her, exploited her, silenced her and even decades after it was supposed to have ended, still acted with a high hand in resolving her affairs…Her name was silence. His was power. Her name was poverty. His was wealth.

For Solnit, the Strauss-Kahn rape was more than a rape of a single woman. It was indicative of an entire system built on intimidation, colonization, and entitlement.

The final essay, “#YesAllWomen,” anticipates the current trending hashtag #MeToo that has grown out of the Harvey Weinstein episode, while her essay, “Cassandra among the Creeps,” indicts a world where countless women report abuse, assault, and violence only to have those reports too often fall on deaf ears.  Again, it is the very situation that allowed the Weinstein abuses to go on for so long.

In a world where intellectual thought has become rare–where it’s very opposite is the norm–Rebeccca Solnit is an American treasure. Her breadth of interests seems inexhaustible and her thinking is clear and logical (another sadly missing aspect of our current times.) Her writing is both entertaining and provocative, and in many cases unforgettable.

I would recommend for all to pick up any one of her books. You will be enthralled and enchanted and awed. And you will certainly learn something that you didn’t know you didn’t know.

And I encourage all men to read Men Explain Things to Me. In the end, we are all in this together.

 

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Book Review: Men Explain Things to Me by Rebecca Solnit

  1. Wonderful piece John…your piece has led me to the library looking for “Solnit”…your statistic about the number of murders of women was jaw-dropping…more than the Twin Towers AND the two wars. You’re right, why isn’t our attention drawn to this grotesque fact of American life? One more statistic that shows how guns in homes are out-of-place despite the Second Amendment that some bow down to before any other…it seems. Then, I think of war profiteering…the very same gun manufacturers’ other big market…Eisenhower’s warning still goes unheeded and our attentions are driven towards the scary foreigners, or other Great Satans on whom a “War” can be declared. Despite our many self-illusions, we are a very war-loving species…or should I say Sex?

  2. John, River of Shadows was the book that started me on Solnit’s writing. I think it’s time to re-read it. I have a travel book for you that I have been meaning to get to you for the last year or so. I will do it. Gerry

    About 4 fingers of bourbon got together with me to listen to her speak: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6XnnAu5LMs

    On Thu, Oct 19, 2017 at 4:47 AM, j. p. bohannon wrote:

    > jpbohannon posted: “At the end of last year or the beginning of this, > before my focus and attention were hijacked by the circus that is American > politics, The New York Times did a piece on what books people had read the > previous year. There were about fifty panelists, mostly” > Respond to this post by replying above this line > New post on *j. p. bohannon* > Book Review: *Men Explain > Things to Me *by Rebecca Solnit > by > jpbohannon > > At the end of last year or the beginning of this, before my focus and > attention were hijacked by the circus that is American politics, *The New > York Times* did a piece on what books people had read the previous year. > There were about fifty panelists, mostly writers, but mixed with a sampling > of actors, scientists, business people, and politicians. What I could not > help but notice is that every third person or so listed two books by > Rebecca Solnit. Not the same two books, but two books. No one, it seemed > read one Rebecca Solnit book; they had always gone on to a second or a > third. > [image: 2083] > > Rebecca Solnit (photograph by John Lee for The Guardian) > > I had done the same a few years earlier. A friend had lent me a copy of *Infinite > City: A San Francisco Atlas > , > *Solnit’s whimsical collection of “should-be” maps of San Francisco > neighborhoods, which had, of course, immediately led me to another title *Wanderlust: > A History of Walking, *which is much more fascinating than it sounds; > as the blurb says, it is a history of walking as a political and cultural > activity. (Solnit has also done atlases of New York and New Orleans.) > > But then I moved on to other books, to other writers, although I did not > forget about her. One couldn’t; she was everywhere: her essays appearing in > journals, her pieces in major newspapers, her name cited in political > commentary, her books brought up in serious conversation. > > This year, after reading the *NYTimes* piece, I realized it had been a > while since I last read her, so I bought and read* A Field Guide to > Getting Lost* in January. However, I did not immediately read another. > Instead, I fell down a rabbit hole of books about walking and cities and > travel: *Flanneuse* by Lauren Elkin, *The Only Street in Paris* by Elaine > Scillonian, *Sidewalks* by Valeria Luiselli and *Time Travel: A History* > by James Gleick. This is what a good book can do. > > So now in early autumn I return to Solnit once more. > > *Men Explain Things to Me* is a [image: menexplain]collection of seven > essays, mostly first-published on the web-site *TomDispatch*, that focus > on the reality and the dangers (and some of the absurdity) found in the > patriarchy of modern civilization, dangers that include murder, violence, > and rape, as well as condescension and subordination. > > The opening essay, “Men Explain Things to Me,” begins with the humorous > anecdote where at a party a man says he heard she was a writer and asks her > what she has written. She mentions the last book she has written–a study > of Eadweard Muybridge and the technology of the west–and he says what a > shame that it was published the same year that another book on the same > subject came out. He then goes on to explain the substance of this “other > book.” As he continues with his description of the book that she should > read, Solnit recognizes that he is talking about *her book*. > > Talk about mansplaining! > >

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s