I had a conversation the other day with a woman who is teaching Marjane Satrapi’s graphic-novel Persepolis. Our discussion revolved around the differences between ethics and morality. Neither of us are professional philosophers, but I like to think that we are thoughtful, intelligent people. And so, we must answer the questions: What is ethical? What is moral?
From the dictionaries I learned that morals are “a person’s standards of behavior or belief’s concerning what is and is not acceptable for them to do” and that ethics are “moral principles that govern person’s or group’s behavior.”
Yet that seems backwards to the way that I have always viewed it. I had viewed morals as being proscribed by a particular group and ethics as being a more personal, individual code of living. Perhaps my association of “groups” with morals is coming from the preponderance of fundamentalists–in all religions–who attempt to press their moral code on all. Ethics to me, on the other hand, is the system of right and wrong, just and unjust, developed individually.
Is this a case where I am just wrong, outright?
So, I went to a man who teaches philosophy. His distinction was this: ethics is a system of right and wrong behavior derived from rationality. Morals is a system derived from religious belief. Yes, many times they overlap. But sometimes they do not.
Yup, that seemed to clear some things up. And I didn’t seem completely off in my understanding.
For instance, according to the religious belief group in charge in the picture above, it is IMMORAL to listen to ABBA. (We are talking ethics and morals here, not musical discernment.) Yet it is hardly UNETHICAL to do so.
So think of the things that are proscribed by particular groups and weigh them in light of ethical or moral. For some, it is marrying outside one’s group (unethical or immoral?); for others, it is believing in evolution (unethical or immoral?); and still for others, it is having men and women sit on the same side of a room (unethical or immoral?).
In the States, we are going through an election season (doesn’t it always seem like an election season) and, in the political debate, social issues always seem to force their way to the top–or at least garner the most attention. Issues of sexuality, women’s reproductive rights, marriage get a lot of discussion. Are these ethical issues or moral issues? In a system that supposedly separates church from state, are the morals of a particular belief system muddying the ethics of a rational system? In other words, I might not want to listen to ABBA but should you tell me I can’t?
I listened to a man speak two weekends ago who suggested that members of the U.S. Congress should read more poetry. He noted that the poet Adrienne Rich once called poetry, in all its ambiguity, the “perfect antidote to moral certainty.” I keep thinking about that and worrying about governmental moral certainty. Other governments have tried it–and it ain’t pretty.
It’s been a while since I read Persepolis or Persepolis 2, and I have never seen the film version. I remember both books as being quick reads, but I have lasting memories of them. Maybe, I’ll go through them again this weekend.
4 thoughts on “Ethical versus Moral”
Who has the right to judge you and tell you what you can do and what you cannot do? Who except for God and your conscience?
I always remember a phrase I liked a lot and that is a good motto: “Love and do what you will”…. The thing is that if you really love (God, people, a partner, your children…) you cannot do all one can imagine/want, you will impose yourself the limits… 🙂
That is I try TO (Not “YO” even though I’m from Philly!)
Yo Adrienne! Heard a lovely boy speak out against hate speech today on stage in front of 450 of his classmates. It was the most amazing feat of courage I have witnessed in a school setting.
I try yo go with the Spike Lee philosophy: Do the Right Thing!